After learning about Google turning over the IP address of an anonymous Israeli blogger, I realized I needed to understand the facts before forging an opinion and went out in search of other articles and more information. Within hours I had also came across the passage in the House of Representatives of a bill, HR1955, entitled the "Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism Prevention Act of 2007" — which, curiously, I’ve seen absolutely nothing about in the mainstream media and it’s on its way to the Senate where it will undoubtedly pass immediately.
How are these two connected?
First go and read the bill (it’s quite short) and pay special attention to Sec 899B wherein "Congress finds the following:". If you don’t come away with the impression that all of these points are amazingly vague and that this bill could easily be gamed by any current or future Administration that, for example, severely compromised habeas corpus or wiretapped domestically without warrants, I’ll eat my hat.
One passage has caused uproar amongst geeks and the blogosphere. Sec 899B, #3, states, "The Internet has aided in facilitating violent radicalization, ideologically based violence, and the homegrown terrorism process in the United States by providing access to broad and constant streams of terrorist-related propaganda to United States citizens." I don’t know about you, but I never see "streams of propaganda" and this smacks of how some in the Justice Department seem to use child pornography as a catch-all for moves to control cyberspace and accelerate tracking mechanisms (who among you could possibly be for child porn? Or terrorism, for that matter? Got something to hide?).
While the outrage over Yahoo turning over a Chinese dissident and now Google turning over an anonymous Israeli blogger’s IP address is understandable, unlike what Yahoo did and AT&T did (by actually first violating the law by implementing wiretapping without a warrant), Google at least waited until an Israeli court order was given.
Here’s what I think is really going on…
Steve’s Social Stuff